-Paridhi Gupta, Mehroo Batra
Kill a dog, smash its head. Watch the blood trickle in your room. Hear the helpless animals wordless scream of agony. Unreal, inhuman, absolutely unacceptable? What about compensation for it: a little money?
On Tuesday, July 8; in the wee hours of morning, a female dog was beaten to death by a JNU student and his two friends, in his hostel room. Yoronso, the accused is a 30-year old from Nagaland who is about to complete his PhD in Political Science. The occupants of Kaveri hostel were woken up by the animal’s wails around 2AM. On demanding, Yoronso opened the door to his room only to reveal the dead stray dog lying in a pool of blood, with its head smashed.
In his letter of apology to the authorities, Yoronso asserts that the reason for this shameful act was merely ‘self-defense’. He claims that the dog had entered his room and when he tried to get it out, it attacked him. In order to penalize Yoronso, he was expelled from the hostel (which he was supposed to leave anyway) and asked to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/-
Meanwhile, animal rights practitioners have moved into campus with some calling JNU a “lawless slaughterhouse�. Lawyer Anjali Sharma of the Citizens for Animals — an association of animal sympathizers — said, “What happened in JNU is an offence under Section 11 of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, and Sections 428 and 429 of the Indian Penal Code.� She added the police are also empowered to arrest such offenders without warrants.
Till when can these animal rights organizations keep fighting? Nothing can be fruitful without the police and faculty’s co-operation. Nobody in their right minds would not be be nauseated at the sight of such a grotesque incident. But our police has wisely chosen to sit back with their arms crossed. If you think that Yoronso is at fault, well then our police who thinks that killing a dog is worth just Rs.2000 is not much better.
The solution to this problem does not lie in penalty and eviction. An abashed act like this one needs to be treated with more seriousness. It has to be made clear that animal rights are a major issue.
An immediate attempt has to be made to gather people to stand up for this cause. Seema Kaemra of the Circle of Animal Lovers (CAL), a Delhi-based animal rights group, said that a mass protest against such incidents that would sensitize people is the call of the day.
“Merely taking action against the student or complaining to the police is not the solution. Informing people about the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act and sensitizing them to a more humane behavior towards animals is what is required.In this case, a campaign with the JNU authorities and with help from the media is what would be more fruitful in the long run,” Kaemra said.
But the question that we would like to ask our readers are, do they care enough?




23 comments
Shruti Rao says:
Jul 12, 2008
Brilliant, brilliant beginning to the article. It’s tough identifying with human beings at times like these, but I’m glad you guys covered it.
Oindrila Duttagupta says:
Jul 13, 2008
yeah….good that you worked on this…and let me tell you,its not only JNU. it happens all the time…and not just dogs! good job.
Swetha says:
Jul 13, 2008
I loved the beginning! Although, I’d really like to know more about this case, we should work on that.
Paridhi Gupta says:
Jul 13, 2008
According to the JNU students, this is not the first time such an incident has taken place in their campus. Last year another Dog was beaten to death right outside the campus! Its a shame, people will never stop.
Danny says:
Jul 13, 2008
Terrible! It’s just sickening to see human beings behave this way shamelessly….
Megha says:
Jul 14, 2008
its a good change..good beginning. Im happy to see Du Beat has taken this initiative as its time we all wake up from our apathy towards the inhuman treatment towards animals which the likes of Yoronso often display
Megha says:
Jul 14, 2008
its a good change..good beginning. Im happy to see Du Beat has taken this initiative as its time we all wake up from our apathy towards the inhuman treatment of animals which the likes of Yoronso often display
shweta sood says:
Jul 14, 2008
really, the callous and sickening attitude of people needs to be changed.i dunno why people relate to life only as “human life”. there is a definite need for sensitization,and stronger enforcement of law.
Priyanka Dhawan says:
Jul 15, 2008
i began to think if these people even have a thing called “feelings or a heart”.this act is barbaric.
Sushmita says:
Jul 15, 2008
Pari,
its not just the end of the story….dese people even kill dogs and cats to please there appetite…
Now what do you say to that!!!
Danny says:
Jul 15, 2008
But in Nagaland (though i may be wrong) dog’s are a delicacy and its a way of life/ culture there…but the context here is different sushmita..and it is in that view that the act becomes heinous! you can not go around condemning someones culture and way of life in the name of upholding some one else’s (even if it is animal ) rights…that’s just plain hypocrisy!
Ansu says:
Jul 15, 2008
R there any good ladies hostels adjacent to Hans Raj College? Also, how far is the college from DU’s North Campus? Is the area safe for women students?
Asang says:
Jul 17, 2008
Hi everyone, I wud like to make a clarification that this guy yoronso is not from Nagaland as reported by the media all over, but he belongs to the Tangkhul community and a resident of manipur. Well such kind of acts may be accepted in local cultures but not in highly advanced societies or institutions of higher learning. Its quite sad that the media acting as the ‘eyes’ and ‘ears’ of the public, given the responsibility as the fourth estate, fail to ascertain the truth of the matter. Such blatant errors might spark epistemic violence.
Sushmita says:
Jul 17, 2008
i know Danny u r absolutely correct.i should have explained my point.
killing for self defense and killing for delicacy.which killing sounds more heinous to u??
my point of mentioning it was just to aware people that crime to us might be a savor to people of Nagaland or in this case a struggle to survive for Yoronso.
im neither justifying Yoronso nor the people of Nagaland or Norway(even they eat dogs).
Sushmita says:
Jul 17, 2008
i know Danny u r absolutely correct.i should have explained my point.
killing for self defense and killing for delicacy.which killing sounds more heinous to u??
my point of mentioning it was just to aware people that crime to us might be a savor to people of Nagaland or in this case a struggle to survive for Yoronso.
im neither justifying Yoronso nor the people of Nagaland or Norway(even they eat dogs).
Tauseef says:
Jul 17, 2008
Yoronso…had a better option ..”HOT DOG” …
Nikhil Ahuja says:
Jul 18, 2008
Well whatever happened was shameless as its equivalent to killing ny other animal including human, intentionally. I wish, we shud thnk n act in a way so dat thes evnts can b stopped n ppl comitting such brutal act shud b punished as in ny othr crime. In the end i wish no one eats “Yoronso”
Danny says:
Jul 19, 2008
you still make it sound as though killing for delicacy (assuming you mean killing to eat since ‘for delicacy’ is grammatically incorrect) is a crime. All i’m saying is that supposed the Chinese kill a cockroach to eat it because it is a delicacy we would not burst into an uproar over that, because after all its his custom right?’ in the same way a custom you cna not impeach by any standards but like Asang has pointed out in JNU campus for whatever reasons killing a dog in cold blood would be a foolish thing to do. Whether it is for self defence or not.
Moreover i”ll ask you, which dog have you come across till date which has not cowered and run when you ‘shooed’ it? Dog’s in the city are different from dogs in the wild here they are acclimatised to human beings and as a result rarely ever attack in such a manner unless cornered and provoked to an extreme.
and yes, something needs to be done. The crime ought to be punished by a penalty so harsh that others as well think twice before being presumptuous enough to take the life of another living creature.
Binu Nair says:
Jul 21, 2008
I am a outsider from JNU..But I want to leave comments on this lead story wrttn by-Paridhi Gupta, Mehroo Batra……What a strong sentences..I can assure they truly and hardly hurt their mind while they were seen this cruelty….I like this type of truely and social cultured issues from students……. To other JNU-s please write your each manuscripts like this way to enrich DUbeat proffessionally..
d0pus says:
Jul 22, 2008
THE FINE WOZ UNNESEORY GUYS.DA DUED SHUD HAVE BEEN MADE TO EAT DA CORPSE.
WOT U KIL IS WOT U EAT
Ankit says:
Jul 30, 2008
dude….its not the fact they killed the dog to eat it……but the way they killed the dog…pulverized the poor defenseless creature and cut it alive for god sake..!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! its a matter animal cruelty!!!! of tell me one thing would u dare stay alone in a locked room with such a person!!!!!!!
Sriya says:
Jul 31, 2008
Sign the petition against Yoronso at http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/jnu-dog-butchered-alive
Zabuza Momochi says:
Nov 10, 2008
Against? Are you kidding me? Wasn’t it enough that he was expelled. LOL. This is exactly what happens when you have an extra dosage of “Ethics” and crap. [yeah, I have the course this sem. never mind]. So now, the dog is dead, and let’s kill the guy who’s alive. Atleast, let us make his life hell.
Btw, /me came across this site from the absolutely awesome [insert: "Sarcasm"] article on molestation of whoever at IITK. Commenting closed? Ouch, I’m hurt.