Ignorance is quite captivating sometimes, its implications often deserve adequate ruminations regardless of whether they happen to be blissful or not. Of all the not so recent news in the North Indian world, what has recently got my goat is the blatant idiocy in the guise of tradition and honour. Now, harmless idiocy is harmless enough but the victimized women in these cases would surely testify it is anything but that. I wouldn’t call myself a feminist but I do agree with their fundamental belief, i.e. all women and men are equal, and their primary cause, to make this true in practise. Call me an idiot but there is no thing as a better sex, just better individuals if you must. For every Medha Patkar there is a Mayawati, and for every Manmohan Singh there is an Advani. Anyhow, lets come back to those two particularly fascinating headlines directly quoted from a couple of priggish village elders. One was regarding what you might now call ancient news, the Noida gang rape case; the geriatric bugger’s view of the grim situation was remarkably simple, “She was just raped, so what?” For a minute, the optimist in me pondered if it could be an error in translation, but then I had to rule out the possibility since the words were too crisp to seem inaccurate; there was no corrigendum over the week. This view was allegedly shared by most of the village; in their opinion, their boys had done no wrong, and they just might be right on this one. The throes of passion notwithstanding are these boys really to blame, having been brought up in such a society where the concept of the modesty of a woman is entirely foreign? Or take the recent Francis Gomes case. Even insanity tends to have a purpose and rationale, however crazy it might be. One could argue that all he did was take the notions of honour and security to an extremely obsessive and somewhat paranoiac level, right?
Then there was the other headline, “Only whores choose their partners”, this one coming from the Chaudhary of a Khap Panchayat. I would hate to contest his wisdom of years, but isn’t it the other way round? Either way, the point is clear, that with such regressive values ingrained in our society we cannot hope to easily overcome these atrocities that are doled out in alarming frequency. Protesting at Jantar Mantar might sound like a noble thing to do but the end result? At the most, you’ll get your picture printed in the next day’s newspaper complete with a profound placard in hand. Condemning such happenings from the comfort of our safe homes is easy, as this article itself might testify. However, if you happen to take it to a further activist level by actually going to these red zones and trying to change things around, may the Gods save your life and might they also punish you for your utter foolishness. These unreasonable and uncivilized practises have been going on and they would go on, and the only plausible way to counter them is, yes, you know it, education! Will Durant said, “Education is a progressive discovery of our ignorance”. It is this self-realization, which then leads to the acquisition of a reasonable temperament and consequently an atmosphere of change.
As the most fundamental principle of Economics goes, resources are limited but wants are not; we must make some compromises, particularly for being a developing nation. Instead of specializations and higher education, the focus must be inclined more towards improving quality of basic education for the masses. We are already producing enough engineers, doctors, lawyers and intellectuals; and yet the female half of the population continues to live in jeopardy even in areas that come under the label of ‘National Capital Region’. Come to think of it, we cannot even afford to employ such retrogressive methods on either side, for it would only further dampen our growth. Maybe we don’t need all those bulletproof planes and precision missiles that could pierce a baby’s bottom from three hundred miles away, or wait, maybe we do not need to make these compromises after all! Our netas are supposedly on an austerity drive, they wouldn’t be flying first class except in ‘certain’ cases. I guess austerity like everything else is relative, isn’t it?
“India Shining”
“Sir, yes, sir!”
“Incredible India”
“Sir, yes, sir!”
“Your ass may belong to Levis, but your soul belongs here”
“Sir, yes, sir!”




2 comments
Aqseer Sodhi says:
Dec 23, 2009
Marvel, why would I not like this?
While I don’t particularly like the phrase “modesty of a woman”, I obviously agree with your sentiment. Interesting observation about the futility of ranting from a safe distance and the stupidity of getting in the dirt yourself.
Education, sure. But education didn’t make our contemporaries all gender-sensitive either. Why do you reckon I’m so pissed off all the time? I don’t live in a khap panchayat governed area. Educated Indians are pretty bad as well. But sure, at least they’ll think twice before saying something of the sort cited above. Oh, excerpt from a piece in HT city a couple of months back, by one Jaydeep Ghosh if memory serves- ladies, no one wants to see you hairy. Keep the fuzz in control, sure men don’t get waxed, but we don’t lift our arms for you to see- or something to the effect.
Also, check out the comments on the pink chaddi campaign blog, for more blatant chauvinism.
Marvel says:
Dec 28, 2009
Ahh, Ms. Sodhi, I’m really glad you like it; which rounds up all the die-hard feminists I happen to know, I guess I have passed the test :D
Oh and I think I said you might like this, or at least that’s what I intended to (I often end up saying things which mean the exact opposite of what I meant to say)
‘Modesty of a woman’, ah well, wannabe journalists must be granted the use of such cliches for they save them from unnecessary elaboration, keeping in mind strict word limits and shite.
As for education, I meant it in it’s truest sense; yes, all that idealistic crap, not the one which is actually dished out in our country.
And yes, I do remember reading that particular column by Jaydeep Ghosh, and now that I think about it, I can imagine you going into conniptions over such a statement. But here’s the thing, I wouldn’t deride him since it’s his opinion in the end, and it is a harmless and somewhat rational one (besides, he is writing for HT City for crying out loud!), and in the end as they say – men will be men!
As for the pink chaddi blog, yes, I did go through that. I have to confess I quite enjoyed reading those insanely exasperating comments.
Anyhow, thanks for reading man. Trust me, after the few short conversations we have had in this regard, I really wanted you of all the people to appreciate it.